DisclosureCheck · The record on this property
Property & Neighborhood Intelligence
Independent research · Public records · Sourced & attributed data
Sample Property (address withheld)
Fernandina Beach, Florida 32034 · Amelia Island · New Construction
Report Date
May 19, 2026
List Price
$1,095,000
Property
3 bd / 3 ba / 2,835 sf
Status
New Construction
County
Nassau
AlertListed at $1,095,000 and $995,000 on different platforms. A $100,000 discrepancy to resolve in writing before any offer.
66
out of 100
Moderate Concern: Favorable Property, Three Items Before Any Offer
New construction in a sought-after waterfront community with strong schools and low crime. Three items need attention first: (1) zip 32034 carries medium-to-high flood risk, with roughly 68% of buildings at risk over 30 years, so verify this parcel's zone and flood insurance cost; (2) the listing appears at two price points; (3) neighboring listings on the same street show extended days on market, which gives you negotiating context. All three are addressable before you sign.
Before you read anything else
★
Verified Location
Sample Property (address withheld)
A subdivision on the northwest side of Amelia Island, about 2.8 miles from downtown Fernandina Beach and roughly 4 miles from Atlantic beach access. Intracoastal-adjacent, not oceanfront.
Public record overview
1
Property Profile & Price History
List Price
$1.095M
New construction
Size
2,835
sq ft living area
Beds / Baths
3 / 3
Full baths
Price / Sq Ft
$386
vs ~$350 area avg
HOA
Yes
Community HOA
CRITICAL · CLARIFY FIRST
Two price points for the same address: $1,095,000 and $995,000
The property appears at $1,095,000 on a local brokerage site and Northeast Florida MLS, and at $995,000 on a national listing portal under a separate record. On new construction, a $100,000 gap needs a written explanation before any offer. It may be a prior list price, a different unit in the same development, or an active discrepancy. Northeast Florida MLSListing portal
Ask the listing agent for the MLS history on this exact address, the current binding price, and any reductions, in writing.
POSITIVE
New construction: no deferred maintenance, current building code
New construction removes the risk of aged systems and pre-2001 Florida Building Code construction. Post-2017 Nassau County permitting requires wind mitigation features that can lower homeowners insurance premiums. Nassau County Building Dept
Request the wind mitigation report from the builder at closing. It is transferable and carriers use it to set discounts.
PRICING CONTEXT
Priced at the top of the range; neighbors sitting on the market
Comparable new construction in the community and nearby Amelia Island sells at roughly $340 to $365 per sq ft; this listing is $386. Zip 32034 averages 82 days on market with homes selling about 2% below list, and several homes on the same street are listed at the same time. This is market context, not an appraisal. Redfin 32034 market dataLocal brokerage listingsBrokerage comparable data
Builders often prefer closing-cost credits or a rate buydown over a price cut, since it protects their per-square-foot pricing on remaining inventory.
Florida-critical data
2
Flood Zone & Evacuation Zone
HIGH FLOOD RISK AREA
Zip 32034: about 68% of buildings carry flood risk over the next 30 years
The subdivision is a waterfront community near the Intracoastal Waterway. The parcel's official zone, Base Flood Elevation and Design Flood Elevation must be checked on the City of Fernandina Beach flood portal before you rely on any insurance estimate. Climate risk data 32034fernandinabeachfl.withforerunner.com
Search this parcel at fernandinabeachfl.withforerunner.com for its zone, BFE and any compliance warnings.
VERIFY
Evacuation zone is separate from flood zone
Nassau County uses All-Hazards Evacuation Zones, which measure storm surge risk and are separate from FEMA flood zones. Given its Intracoastal location, the subdivision is likely in one of the higher-priority zones. Confirm the zone for this exact parcel. Nassau County Emergency Management
Look up the parcel at onenassau.com/know-your-zone and save the result.
POSITIVE · CRS DISCOUNT
Fernandina Beach is CRS Class 5: 25% off flood insurance in special flood hazard areas
Fernandina Beach's Community Rating System class gives a 25% discount on flood premiums for properties in a Special Flood Hazard Area. If this parcel is confirmed in one, the discount applies automatically. City of Fernandina Beach Flood Protection Program
Public safety data
3
Neighborhood Intelligence: The Community
SummaryA planned residential community on the northwest side of Amelia Island, one of Florida's most historically preserved barrier islands, with waterfront and water-view homes along the Intracoastal and tidal marshes. Nassau County is one of the fastest-growing counties in Northeast Florida.
NOTE
Crime data is zip-level, not block-level
These figures cover zip 32034 as a whole. A private residential community often runs lower than the zip average, but that is not guaranteed for any specific street. CrimeGradeHomefacts 32034
Check neighborhood-level data at crimegrade.org and the FDLE registry at fdle.florida.gov.
Independently sourced
4
Assigned Schools: Nassau County School District
Elementary · verify assignment
Emma Love Hardee Elementary
Serves the area · district averages 73% math proficiency
A-
Middle · verify assignment
Fernandina Beach Middle School
#175 in Florida (U.S. News) · 77% math, 62% reading proficiency
A-
High · verify assignment
Fernandina Beach High School
#138 in Florida (U.S. News) · 45% AP participation · 97% graduation
A
STRONG POSITIVE
One of Northeast Florida's top districts
Nassau County serves about 12,575 students across 24 schools, with 73% proficient in math and 66% in reading, against state averages of 52% and 50%. U.S. NewsGreatSchoolsNiche
Boundaries change. Confirm assignment with the district school locator at nassau.k12.fl.us.
Noise and flight corridors
5
Airports & Flight Paths
LOW IMPACT
Fernandina Beach Airport (FHB), 2.8 miles northwest: small general aviation field
FHB handles light aircraft and small charters only, with no commercial airline service. Based on published FAA sectional data, the property is not under its primary approach or departure corridors. FAA airport data
NOTE
Jacksonville International (JAX), about 28 miles southwest
JAX commercial corridors run predominantly northeast-southwest along the St. Johns River, away from Amelia Island. FAA facility dataSkyVector
EPA ECHO database
6
Environmental Hazards
LOW INDUSTRIAL RISK
No major facilities with active violations within 5 miles
The nearest industrial corridor is on the mainland near US-1 and the rail line, roughly 6 to 8 miles west. Nassau County AQI readings are consistently in the Good range. EPA ECHOEPA AirNow
AWARENESS
Historic paper industry operations near the waterfront
Fernandina Beach has hosted paper mill and industrial operations historically. Buyers sensitive to air quality should check current facility and compliance data directly. EPA ECHO
echo.epa.gov → Facility Search → this address → 5-mile radius.
Association health
7
HOA: The Community
VERIFY WITH SELLER
Deed-restricted PUD, no public complaints found
The community is a deed-restricted Planned Unit Development. No active disciplinary actions or complaints against its HOA management appeared in Florida DBPR records as of this report. Fees can change during a community's buildout phase. Florida DBPRNassau County property records
Current HOA budget
Reserve balance and reserve study
12 months of board minutes
Pending or approved special assessments
Master insurance declarations page
Declaration of covenants (CC&Rs)
Rules and architectural guidelines
Current monthly fee and pending increases
Taxes and utilities
8
Property Taxes, Homestead & Utilities
Est. Annual Taxes
~$9,500
~0.87% effective rate, Nassau County
Homestead
File by Mar 1
If primary residence
Save Our Homes
3% cap
On assessed value once homesteaded
Electric
FPL
~$2,400–$3,600/yr est.
Florida insurance market
9
Insurance Reality: Nassau County / 32034
INVESTIGATE EARLY
Coastal market with fewer carriers writing since 2024
Several private carriers have reduced new policies in coastal Nassau County zips. Estimates for this home: homeowners $4,000 to $8,000 a year, a separate wind policy $2,000 to $4,000, and flood $3,000 to $8,000 if Zone AE before the CRS discount. Florida OIRCitizens eligibility map
Get quotes from at least three carriers early in due diligence, not right before closing.
PLANNING
Wind mitigation credits can cut premiums 20% to 40%
Homes built to post-2001 Florida Building Code qualify for wind mitigation credits. The builder's wind mitigation report is what carriers use to apply them. Florida OIRFHCF
Beyond the mortgage
10
Estimated Cost of Ownership
| Property taxes, Nassau County (~0.87%) | ~$9,500/yr |
| Homeowners insurance, wind mitigated (estimate) | $4,000–$8,000/yr |
| Wind policy if written separately | $2,000–$4,000/yr |
| Flood insurance if Zone AE, after 25% CRS discount | $2,250–$6,000/yr |
| HOA dues | Request from seller |
| Electric, FPL (estimate) | ~$2,400–$3,600/yr |
| Maintenance reserve (0.5% rule, new build) | ~$5,475/yr |
| Estimated annual carrying cost, excluding HOA | $25,000–$37,000/yr |
All figures are estimates. Get actual insurance quotes before making any financial commitment.
Before you sign anything
11
Priority Flags & Buyer Action Plan
Resolve before making any offer
Verify the flood zone and BFE at fernandinabeachfl.withforerunner.com
Get the binding list price and MLS history in writing from the listing agent
Request the HOA documents and three insurance quotes during the inspection period
Priority 1 · Before any offer
Verify the flood zone
Search the parcel for its official zone, Base Flood Elevation and any compliance warnings. If it is Zone AE, get flood quotes immediately.
Priority 2 · Before any offer
Resolve the two prices in writing
Ask which MLS record governs and what the binding price is. A $100,000 gap needs an explanation before you write a number.
Priority 3 · Inspection period
HOA documents and insurance quotes
Request all eight HOA items above and quotes from at least three carriers at the same time.
Priority 4 · At or before closing
Get the wind mitigation report
It costs the builder nothing to provide and can lower your premium every year you own the home.
Public Portals for Independent Verification · Nassau County
Every finding in this report comes from publicly available data. Verify each item directly.
Flood zone, parcel-levelfernandinabeachfl.withforerunner.com
FEMA flood mapmsc.fema.gov/portal
Evacuation zoneonenassau.com/know-your-zone
Nassau County Property Appraisernassauflpa.com
Fernandina Beach permitsfbfl.us
School locatornassau.k12.fl.us
Crime datacrimegrade.org
Sex offender registryfdle.florida.gov
EPA environmental dataecho.epa.gov
HOA registrationmyfloridalicense.com
Insurance marketfloir.com
Flight dataskyvector.com
DisclosureCheck™
This report is an informational research summary based on publicly available records, listing data, and published sources as of May 19, 2026. Reports are researched and written by AI from public sources. Sources are attributed for each finding. DisclosureCheck™ is an independent research service, not a licensed real estate broker, agent, attorney, inspector, or appraiser. Nothing in this report is legal, financial, or real estate advice, and the DisclosureCheck Score is our opinion based on the findings. Cost figures are estimates. Verify all findings with qualified professionals before closing. One fee covers one property.